Last update: 25/09/2018, Dr. Miguel B. Royo Salvador, Medical Board number 10389. Neurosurgeon y Neurologist.
In the publication, “Herniated disc in the workplace […]“, and in other similar publications, our results are evaluated and compared, obtaining a significant difference in favor of our surgical techniques as a solution to herniated inkumbar discs.
The most frequent neurosurgical intervention is the herniated lumbar disc. In relation to this, patients frequently ask:
The majority of sciaticas have a cure and in general with an easy treatment.
95% of sciatica cases heal or improve with rest, lying down and with the help of anti-inflammatories and analgesics.
The body carries out the healing process. The anti-inflammatory improve the inflammation caused by the compression of a nerve root. The analgesics or painkillers alleviate the pain from the nerve root and its territory.
Nevertheless, it is necessary to explain some basic concepts to understanding what happens with a sciatica:
It is called sciatica or sciatic pain when the pain coincides with the sciatic nerve path which extends from the lumbar area to the back side of the lower extremity, from which comes lumbosciatic or lumbociatalgia.
If the pain radiates to the front side of the lower extremity, coinciding with the path of the crural nerve, the pain is called cruralgia.
It is important to differentiate between the two as it orients us as to which nerve roots are affected.
The sciatic pain, lumbosciatic or lumbociatalgia is frequently caused by the compression of the nerve root by a herniated lumbar disc. But in many occasions, this pain is caused by lumbar facet joints syndrome which is explained further ahead.
A herniated lumbar disc consists of the loss of the cushion situated in the cartilage intervertebral disc that unites two vertebras. The intervertebral disc is formed by a hard external cartilaginous layer called the annulus fibrosa and another that fills the soft center called the nucleus pulpous.
When the annulus fibrosa loses height, tears or breaks and lets out part of the nucleus pulpous, it forms a herniated disc.
As the protrusion or herniated disc occupies an abnormal space, it compresses the structures that are adjacent to the intervertebral disc; if these are the nerves that go to the inferior extremities, it produces injuries which can cause pain, loss of sense of touch and paralysis. Both the protrusion and the herniated disc are considered, for practical purposes, the same but do not indicate in themselves the need for surgery.
There are some wrong concepts, for example, if you have a herniated disc, you must have surgery but not if you have a protrusion. Surgery is not decided by the type of disc alteration but is decided by the clinic and the neurological exploration when dealing with a sciatica caused by disc compression. There are many herniated discs without symptoms and it is not for that reason that they should be operated on. If, on the contrary, there are disc protrusions that produce paralysis, they must be operated on urgently.
El TAC y la RM sólo orientan dónde se encuentra y el tipo de compresión nerviosa, en caso de que exista criterio para intervenir nos muestran donde hay que hacerlo. El TAC y la RM no indican si hay que intervenir, ni cuando.
EMG and the electroneurogram (ENG) are a complementary exploration that measure nerve and muscle activity. In a lumbosciatica it advises us as to the type and magnitude of a detectable neurological injury. Not all of the injuries that we see in a neurological exploration are detected in the ENG or EMG.
Most lumbosciaticas are cured with rest and medical and physical therapy measures which alleviate the consequences of the compressed nerves caused by a protrusion or herniated disc. The organism cures itself when it can restore and consolidate the alteration of the intervertebral disc in a way that there won´t be any active nerve injury or instability or overloaded vertebras.
With an anti-inflammatory treatment we can reduce the inflammation of the nerve compressed by the intervertebral deformed disc and therefore, the pain. With analgesic treatment, the pain is reduced before the anti-inflammatory takes effect, and also while the anti-inflammatory is taking effect, as by itself, it is not enough to alleviate the pain. Rest has two aims, one is to reduce the pressure against the nerve root and to give the organism the possibility to repair the deformity of the intervertebral disc.
Physical therapy has various purposes for a lumbosciatica:
Physical therapy that applies greater pressure to the intervertebral discs can aggravate the illness and even cause it in other intervertebral discs that are predisposed, that is why physical therapy must be done or directed by an expert of the spinal cord.
There are clear criteria for a surgical indication of a herniated disc, it is indicated when the patient present at least two of the following criteria:
When surgery is advised because of acute or chronic pain, it depends on the criteria of the patient and the degree of disability. When surgery is advised because of neurologic impairment, loss of strength, feeling or alterations of the sphincters, the surgery should be done “slowly but surely”. If the loss of strength becomes total, the liberating intervention will not achieve an improvement.
In the lumbar disc herniation, there are as many diagnoses as clinical histories. Similarly, there are many surgical indications depending upon each patient’s condition as exist as many surgical approaches as surgeons. The end result is the art healing the herniated disc. Generally, there are three purposes in the surgeries lumbar disc herniation: the first and the most important is to release the nerve compression, the second is to fix the vertebral segment and the third is to maintain the height of the intervertebral disc.
By entering this link you can consult the commentary on the protocol followed to choose the type of surgery for the lumbar herniated disc, as performed at the ICSEB. An article called “The lumbar disc herniation in the workplace. Results of a retrospective analysis of a series of 189 consecutive patients.” (Spanish) was published by the Journal of Neurology (Rev Neurol. 1998 Oct; 27(158):574-6). Here the best results of the whole equivalent consulted bibliography mentioned in textbooks and on Medline® database from 1966-1998 were obtained.
Our method in graphic form:
“To look for the best results with the minimum aggression”. The possible techniques that we apply for the surgical treatment of the herniated lumbar disc with contrasting results have the purpose of eliminating the pressure on the nerve root and in some, to preserve the height of the disc and stabilize the spine. They are classified as:
1. Minimally invasive techniques, such as percutaneous nucleotomy and chemonucleoolysis.
2. Microsurgical techniques using protocolized surgical technique to be applied with optical aids.
3. Lumbar laminectomy: an opening in the spine eliminating the posterior portion of a vertebra or lamina of at least one lumbar vertebra.
4. Lumbar arthrodesis: uses fusion systems with or without grafts that solidify vertebras or parts of them.
To choose the most useful technique and at the same time, the least aggressive, it is necessary to clearly specify the type of compression of the nerve root and the condition of the spine.
When we consider that there is only radicular compression, the least aggressive technique is chosen from the first three ones mentioned, according to the size, location and characteristics of the texture of the radicular compression.
If an apparent vertebral instability exists, a lumbar arthrodesis will be indicated. The criterion for instability varies a lot according different surgeons. In our case, we only proceed with lumbar arthrodesis when the lateral functional x-rays, in flexion and extension, show that there is a clear movement abnormality of vertebral column and this can be responsible for the symptoms that the patient suffers. With this criterion only three lumbar arthrodeses were indicated, out of 189 consecutive patients to undergo a lumbar spine procedure; one case with only one bone graft and the others with two instrumented arthrodeses and bone graft. The kind of arthrodesis varies depending on the type of instability and the surgeon’s habits.
The front part of the vertebrae support each others most important mass or the lumbar vertebrae separated by the intervertebral disc. Behind and on each side they are joined together by the so-called interapophyseal that depend on the height of the intervertebral disc for comfort. If the intervertebral disc decreases in height because the person is standing upright for a long time, the interapophyseal joints become compressed and so cause lumbar pain, or lumbago, in a person without a lumbar disease due to fatigue.
In some patients with interapophyseal joints arthrosis or if the intervertebral disc space, with or without a herniated disc collapses, the interapophyseal joints emit a lumbar pain even at rest. This pain sometimes irradiates downwards towards into the legs without the nerve root being affected to compress the herniated discs.
In cases like these, the patient has the symptoms of a lumbosciatica and nothing appears in the additional testing, the magnetic resonance or CT scans, or on the EMG.
When a LFJS is suspected, because the patient has lumbosciatica with negative neurological examination and additional testing, the procedure is to give a diagnostic injection with a local anaesthetic when the patient has his/her usual pain. The injection is given into the nerve area of the interapophyseal joint, responsible for the pain, with the help of a x-ray TV machine. If the pain improves, it is a LFJS.
To stop the painful discomfort of SFA , a nerve of the interapofisaria joint is damaged to stop the transmission of pain. This is similar to the way a dentist eliminates the possible pain when a tooth is extracted. There are various techniques, in our case we have selected electrocoagulation with high frequency current for its´ precision and safety, with excellent results.
Our English Department is at your disposal to help you with your enquiries.
All consultations received through this form or through the different email addresses of the 'Institut Chiari & Siringomielia & Escoliosis de Barcelona' are derived to the medical team to be studied and are supervised by Dr. Miguel B. Royo Salvador.
* It is imperative to tick this box.
Monday to Thursday: 9-18h (UTC +1)
Friday: 9-15h (UTC +1)
Saturday and Sunday closed
Pº Manuel Girona 16,
Barcelona, España, CP 08034
The Institut Chiari & Siringomielia & Escoliosis de Barcelona (ICSEB) complies with the established in EU regulation 2016/679 (GDPR).
The contents of this website are a non-official translation of the original content of the website in Spanish. The translation is courtesy of the Institut Chiari & Siringomielia & Escoliosis de Barcelona with the purpose of facilitating comprehension for anyone who wishes to Access the website.